Page 1 of 1

"The Artist" color vs. black and white question

PostPosted: Sun May 12, 2019 15:04 +0000
by jabba359
I was flipping through Usagi Yojimbo Saga book 8 and noticed that The Artist and Buntori are reprinted in color. While I had read The Artist in color before (in the single issue) and also in black and white (in Usagi Yojimbo vol. 29: Two Hundred Jizo), as I looked at the color reprinting I couldn't remember how the watercolor art that "the Artist" paints in the story translated to a black and white image. I was surprised to discover that rather than being a monochromatic version of the watercolor, it was a new piece of line art.

My questions to Stan are, what was the process for putting that art into the story? Did you paint watercolor directly onto the original comic book page line art, or were the watercolors created separately and then edited in? When it came to reprinting in the trade, was there a test to see if the watercolors could be reproduced in the black and white format satisfactorily, or did you always plan on doing a line art version for the non-color release?

Re: "The Artist" color vs. black and white question

PostPosted: Sun May 12, 2019 15:34 +0000
by Maka
Good questions. Check out the artist edition #2 (the big book of original scanned pages). I’m not at home right now, but I remember it being blank. Stan painted it separately and with the magic of computers(I think, I could be wrong here) they merged the two.

I’m Stan will correct my errors. :D

Peace, maka

Re: "The Artist" color vs. black and white question

PostPosted: Sun May 12, 2019 16:11 +0000
by jabba359
Maka wrote:Good questions. Check out the artist edition #2 (the big book of original scanned pages). I’m not at home right now, but I remember it being blank. Stan painted it separately and with the magic of computers(I think, I could be wrong here) they merged the two.

I’m Stan will correct my errors. :D

Peace, maka


Ah, I hadn't thought of that book! I mean, it's only called "Gallery Edition Volume 2: The Artist and Other Stories," but it never even crossed my mind that I'd find the art in there. :roll: Haha, I missed the obvious. That also fits my initial impression, as to my eye it looks like a digitally merged image rather than being physically painted onto the same page as the art.

My copy is in a box in storage so I can't pull it out to look right now (Long story short: I boxed up a bunch of stuff and put it in my storage unit a few months back when I was going to move, but the new place fell through and so I left the stuff in storage since I would still like to move at some point in the nearish future :wink:). But if you're recalling the blank part correctly, then that certainly answers part of my question. Thanks!

Re: "The Artist" color vs. black and white question

PostPosted: Sun May 12, 2019 17:58 +0000
by Steve Hubbell

Re: "The Artist" color vs. black and white question

PostPosted: Sun May 12, 2019 18:19 +0000
by jabba359
Thanks Steve! So it looks like the line art was drawn onto the original page (foresight that they'd be needed for the black and white trades, perhaps?) and then watercolors done on a separate template to match the shape within the panel.

Re: "The Artist" color vs. black and white question

PostPosted: Sun May 12, 2019 19:43 +0000
by Stan Sakai
jabba359 wrote:Thanks Steve! So it looks like the line art was drawn onto the original page (foresight that they'd be needed for the black and white trades, perhaps?) and then watercolors done on a separate template to match the shape within the panel.


That is it exactly.

Re: "The Artist" color vs. black and white question

PostPosted: Mon May 13, 2019 15:26 +0000
by Chopalong Slashity
Man, I can't decide which I like more. The colored version is beautiful, but Stan's lineart sometimes adds a certain "gritty" quality to it...