The Complete Fantagraphics Usagi Yojimbo
Moderators: Mayhem, Steve Hubbell, digulla, Moderators
- Steve Hubbell
- Taisho
- Posts: 6050
- Joined: Thu Sep 19, 2002 15:25 -0700
- Location: Kalamazoo, MI
I received my copy from Amazon a couple days ago, and it looks great!.
I had to open the shrink wrap to look it over.
Glad I did because I found a spot in volume 2 around the 560 page point where the binding was damaged (ripped). Amazon already has a replacement copy on its way and I have to drop the original off at UPS to return it.
My copy ordered through the local comic shop also came in and is waiting for pick-up this weekend.
I had to open the shrink wrap to look it over.
Glad I did because I found a spot in volume 2 around the 560 page point where the binding was damaged (ripped). Amazon already has a replacement copy on its way and I have to drop the original off at UPS to return it.
My copy ordered through the local comic shop also came in and is waiting for pick-up this weekend.
- shaxper
- Daimyo <High-Ranking Lord>
- Posts: 823
- Joined: Mon Jun 14, 2004 21:40 -0700
- Location: Lakewood, Ohio
- Contact:
Got mine today.
I think the presentation could have been stronger (binding is a little sloppy, cover and interior art could have reflected more effort), but you just can't go wrong with a complete hardcover collection of the entire Fantagraph run in two volumes, no matter what it looks like.
All in all, I've been nearly frozen in a ridiculously pleased stupor since this came in the mail today.
I think the presentation could have been stronger (binding is a little sloppy, cover and interior art could have reflected more effort), but you just can't go wrong with a complete hardcover collection of the entire Fantagraph run in two volumes, no matter what it looks like.
All in all, I've been nearly frozen in a ridiculously pleased stupor since this came in the mail today.
-
- Shugyosha<Student Warrior>
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2008 20:29 -0700
Got mine yesterday, had to return one because first copy got dinged in shipping. Amazon replaced it overnight with no hassles whatsoever. A+ for them.
The edition itself is very nice, I am very pleased with the use of coated stock.
Some niggling notes: The printing was, however, uneven--as I noted several pages throughout both volumes experienced ink transfer. Anybody else see that? The reproduction of the art in the second book also seemed be heavier than the first book, although I'm not sure if the originals were printed that way as well. I also wouldn't have minded Stan's story notes were alongside as well as indications of where the story first appeared (I'm not so versed in UY I know right off the bat).
Overall, I'm very happy with having the Fantagraphics run done so well and look forward to reading the stories again and again.
The edition itself is very nice, I am very pleased with the use of coated stock.
Some niggling notes: The printing was, however, uneven--as I noted several pages throughout both volumes experienced ink transfer. Anybody else see that? The reproduction of the art in the second book also seemed be heavier than the first book, although I'm not sure if the originals were printed that way as well. I also wouldn't have minded Stan's story notes were alongside as well as indications of where the story first appeared (I'm not so versed in UY I know right off the bat).
Overall, I'm very happy with having the Fantagraphics run done so well and look forward to reading the stories again and again.
Got mine yesterdays, very well packed by amazon and it came without any damages. The edition is very nice, however, i don´t like the fact that the covers are not included before the stories. I don´t know if they are all included at the end of the second book, but i´d rather have them placed before every issue.
Otherwise, it is a very nice book(s), and comparing to Punisher omnibus by Garthe Ennis or similar books, you can actually read them without using all of your arm mucles;-)). Also the size iz ok - i´d like to have all Usagi Yojimbo stories published like this so let´s hope Dark Horse makes something similar in the future as Fantagraphics.
Otherwise, it is a very nice book(s), and comparing to Punisher omnibus by Garthe Ennis or similar books, you can actually read them without using all of your arm mucles;-)). Also the size iz ok - i´d like to have all Usagi Yojimbo stories published like this so let´s hope Dark Horse makes something similar in the future as Fantagraphics.
- Stan Sakai
- Sensei
- Posts: 4896
- Joined: Wed Sep 18, 2002 12:21 -0700